Friday, January 9, 2015

Difference between Cinnamon, Mate, KDE and Xfce - Explained



This particular blog entry is intended for new users to Linux Mint. But some more experiences users might find useful info here as well.

When a new user goes to download Linux Mint for install on their computer (from website http://www.linuxmint.com/download.php), they have a choice of 4 desktop environments; Cinnamon, Mate, KDE and Xfce. Also they have to pick between version with a codecs or without, and 64-bit vs 32-bit.

Confusing?
     What's the difference?
          Which one should you pick?
That's what I hope to explain in this short blog entry.



So, what's the difference between Cinnamon, Mate, KDE and Xfce?

The difference is that these are 4 different desktop environments. That's to say, they are 4 different ways that Linux Mint looks on your screen, and behaves.

Think of it this way, if you have 4 different cars that are all the same make and model, but one is red with a stereo, one is blue and has stick shift, one is yellow and no AC, and one is black with a sun roof. Each is very different in their look and features. But under the hood, they are are all the same. The Linux Mint 'engine' (called the Kernel) are all the same for all versions of 17.1. It's the appearance on the screen and a few of the features that are different. 

And just as all 4 cars can be driven down the same road, all 4 desktop environments will run the same software packages.


Here is a very short rundown of the differences:


CINNAMON

The Cinnamon desktop environment is the one I highly recommend for people who are new to Linux Mint. That is assuming you are installing it on a laptop or workstation that is less than 8 years old. If your hardware is more than 8 years old, I suggest you check into the MATE environment (see bellow).

Cinnamon requires less actual memory (RAM) than Mate, but it does require much more CPU and video resources. On older hardware, this extra load can result in a very slow system. Also, some older graphics cards can't handle Cinnamon at all, and you will get a screen full of junk when you boot up. If that is the case, I suggest you use another computer to download the Mate version and install it.

The big advantage of Cinnamon is its ability to do some animations (like the rotating cube demo), semi transparent windows like the Terminal, and a very smooth opening and closing of windows. As far as actual functionality, it does everything that Mate does.

Most people pick Cinnamon. It just looks cooler and does everything most people need.

Note: Be sure to read what I have to say about Mate (bellow) before you pick this one.



MATE

Pronounced like 'Matt-Tay', this desktop environment is primarily for older hardware which may have issues with the slick graphics of Cinnamon. As far as actual functionality, it does everything that Cinnamon does, only not as pretty. If you are using a laptop or workstation that's older than 8 years old, I would recommend the MATE desktop environment for new users.

Some people who do have newer hardware pick Mate just out of personal preference. They prefer the simpler look and feel of the environment. In such a case, it just comes down to what you like.

Isaac's Computer Tips” has a wonderful YouTube video showing a side by side comparison between Cinnamon and Mate.

Note: I myself have 3 very older systems, and Mate is the version that I use on all 3.


MATE OEM

Do NOT install this version. This is a very small, bare-bones version of MATE. It is intended to be used by manufactures as a “pre-installed” version of Linux. Basically, it can run an in-store demo to show off the systems speed and graphics. It does NOT do much else.


KDE

KDE is a desktop environment is designed for advanced users. It's more “Windows” like in appearance than the others environments. The advantage of KDE is that it gives the user many configuration options and extra widgets not found in the other environments; allowing the user to customize their system to their liking. However, many people new to Linux Mint would probably find it very confusing, and a bit overwhelming. I would not recommend it for new users. I recommend starting with Cinnamon or Mate, and then graduating to KDE down the road, if you feel you really need to.


Xfce

Like Mate, Xfce is primarily for older hardware which many have issues with the demands of Cinnamon. It is fast, easy, and simple. It is a very bare-bone, minimalist desktop environment. It reminds me very much of Linux distros of years past. However, it does NOT come with several key packages built-in that I think many new users would expect. I would NOT recommend this for a system you plan to use for entertainment or business work. However, if you are looking for a very simple environment to learn about Linux itself, this one can't be beet. If you are a student and learning about the Linux OS, go for this one.




Versions of Linux Mint with “No Codecs”

Basically, a codecs (pronounced like 'Code-Ex') is a software package that allows you to watch moves from a DVD drive, play music CD-Roms, and watch some videos over the Internet.

In some cases, businesses are legally obligated to pay a fee to have this software on their corporate PCs. If the PC is NOT a corporate PC, don't worry about it.

Most people just download the version that has the codece.

If you still have questions about this, I would recommend you read this short White Paper on the subject for clarification.



32-bit vs. 64-bit

Most versions of Linux Mint come in both a 32-bit and 64-bit version. This refers to the type of CPU you have in your computer.

The rule of thumb here is this: almost all modern day computers are 64-bit, so go with that version. If you have one of the very rare systems that is 32-bit, it will give you an error message when you try to install Linux Mint. In that case, use another computer to download the 32-bit version and use that one.



Now that you have picked the version of Linux Mint you want and have downloaded it, what to do next?


Go to one of the following websites depending on which version you have picked. These are the Official Linux Mint Users Guides for each version. Take some time to read it over. The first time you install Linux Mint, it might be helpful to also have this document on another PC or your cell phone in case you need to refer to it during the processes.

CINNAMON:


MATE:


KDE & Xfce:
There is no offical guide from these versions at this time. Use the one above for Cinnamon to install theses.



Good luck, and see ya'll on-line :)




No comments:

Post a Comment